Another $1,000 Record, This One in VG Condition

We’ve been keeping an eye lately on jazz LPs that sell for more than $1,000, which is particularly interesting in light of some of the softness we’re seeing in other parts of the market. The LP True Blue by Tina Brooks, Blue Note 4041, is one that has broken the $1,000 many times. It is quite rare. In the Jazz Collector Price Guide, we’ve seen a copy go for as much as $2,075. So, we were watching this copy of True Blue this week to see what would happen in a soft market. The record wound up selling for $1,625. What makes this more interesting is that the vinyl was only in VG condition (the cover was VG++). It’s not so unusual these days for rare Blue Notes to top $1,000, but $1,625 for a record in VG condition, is still pretty high. Part of it attests to the rarity of this particular LP, and part, also, to the underlying soundness of the market, at least for the higher-end LPs.

I do have a personal experience with this LP to share:

I was working a record show as a seller for the first time. This was maybe 20 years ago, pre-eBay and before many collectors realized there was a growing demand for original jazz LPs — i.e., that people would pay hundreds of dollars for items they had bought for less than five dollars. I was not a dealer — I’m still not, even though I sell stuff on eBay — but I had a lot of duplicates to get rid of and, I figured, if I had a table I could get into the show early and perhaps score some nice collectibles. It turned out the guy next to me, had boxes of rare collectibles he was selling for $5 each. Except one of the big dealers had accosted him outside the show, before he had a chance to get set up, and got most of his best stuff, including a mint original pressing of True Blue. It broke my heart. 

Anyway, I chatted the guy up during the course of the day and it turns out he didn’t bring everything: “I have hundreds more at home,”  he said. “I didn’t realize people were interested in them.” I worked it out to go to his house at 8 a.m. the next day. He said he was a late riser, but he liked me, so he’d get up early. “But, please, don’t come before 8,” he said. So I got there precisely at 8 and knocked on the door and peered into the living room and there, poring through shelves of records, was the same dealer who the previous day had beaten me to True Blue. Arrgghh. Anyway, I rushed over to the shelves and started pulling records and wound up with a pile of about 35 records. Nothing like True Blue, but a pretty nice score. When I went to pay the guy he said the prices had gone up since the day before. Instead of $5 a record, they were now $10. I happily pulled out $350 cash and got out of there as fast as I could, before he doubled the price once more.

(Visited 23 times, 1 visits today)

5 comments

  • I have a strange story about True Blue : I bought my NM True Blue a many years ago. I found a guy who had an incredible stock of NM Blue Notes. The same day (!) i also bought : , Lee MOrgan Indeed (lex kakubuchi !), Capuchin Swing, Lee way, Off to the Races, Byrd in Hand, Face to Face, and the other Willette And another Grant Green Feelin the spitit) ! I took the metro with my little plastic bag, full of incredible gems. It was the greatest catch of my collector’s life !!!!!!!

  • I had a similar experience, though not as good. Years ago, probably 25, I walked into a Titus-Oaks record store in Hicksville, Long Island. This used to be in a Wetson’s hamburger joint. I’d go to Titus-Oaks every couple of weeks as part of my regular rounds. This particular day, I wasn’t sure I wanted to go, but I was in the area. They had just put out a batch of Blue Notes that were never played — must have been some guy that worked for Blue Note, took them home and then just dumped them. Among the items I recall: Lee Morgan Lee Way; Pete La Roca Basra; Sonny Redd Out of the Blue; Herbie Hancock Maiden Voyage. These were $5 each. Oh, to be back in those times!

  • Rudolf A. Flinterman

    Al, I am beating you. The scene: Bergenfield N.J. in the sixties, at Prestige. Bob Weinstock introduced me to the crew. Al Johnson, stock manager/ administration. He showed me the stockroom with thousands of “returned” albums, unsold stocks from N.J./N.Y. record stores, to be destroyed in a couple of days. I could take as many as I liked for 50 cts a piece! I selected 300, many doubles, triples of the likes of “Musings of Miles”, “Hope meets Foster”, 2 Guitars, 2 Trumpets, 3 Trumpets, All Day Long, All Night Long, Informal Jazz, all the M.D. quintets, Red Garland, Jimmy Raney, etc. etc. Speaking about a happy day.

  • Rudolf, with that story I think you are beating EVERYONE. That is very cool. — al

  • Please no more of these stories. I don’t know how much more my heart (and wallet) can take.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *